Acceptance of Circumstances, digital analytics, digital marketing agency, Google Analytics, marketing analytics, Results Analysis, strategic planning, website

Which Google Analytics Website KPIs No Longer Make Sense To Track & Analyze Because Of Spam and AI Bot Visitor Upticks?

I’ve been talking to clients (and with SEO and marketing colleagues on LinkedIn), about the huge uptick in spam and AI bot traffic since fall 2025, and I’ve shared the following on some clients’ monthly dashboard reports and/or in e-mails to them: “analyzing overall/total website traffic and making comparisons to previous months’ figures no longer makes sense. Across all industries, site traffic volumes are up significantly because of increased spambot (also spelled as two words “spam bot) and AI agent bots/AI bots visiting/scraping websites. Most of this traffic is earmarked as “direct” traffic by Google Analytics and many organizations are seeing a big uptick in their direct traffic.”

I promised in a LinkedIn post comment related to the AI and spam bot uptick that I would take the time to document which data available in Google Analytics it still make sense to track and analyze. So, here goes:

  • Traffic volume at the specific defined traffic source or user source/medium level to ascertain how much traffic your site is getting from various marketing vehicles or tactics, such as e-mail marketing, social media posts, social media advertising, paid search (Google Ads), or traditional search (organic search) engines, vs. how much traffic the site as a whole is getting
  • Engagement rate at the defined traffic source level vs. the overall website engagement rate (average engagement rate across total website visitors, which, unfortunately, includes direct visitors)
  • Page views at the defined traffic source level
  • Time on site at the defined traffic source level
  • Conversion rate at the defined traffic source or user source medium level — to learn what specific marketing activities/vehicles are converting, i.e., causing visitors to complete desired events, such as clicking on an e-mail link or phone # link, completing a form, or making a purchase
  • Referral traffic by specific domain/URL — while we don’t want or need to be analyzing spam bot or AI bot traffic, and likely can’t since Google Analytics is currently rolling such traffic up into “direct” traffic, it is very beneficial to know from what external websites, if any, your site is receiving traffic (backlinks), and to see if you are receiving traffic from prompts/searches completed in AI tools such as Google Gemini, Microsoft Co-pilot, Perplexity, Claude and ChatGPT. Such referral traffic indicates that the source in-question is including a link back to your site in the results they share in response to a user prompt/search and that you are getting important AI citations.
This is a light gray rectangular shape image that runs vertically that says "In This Age Of AI, Are You Tracking & Analyzing Website Data That Is No Longer Meaningful Nor Data You Can Act On?" and the image also contains the logo of our digital marketing agency, Results Communications & Research

What’s The Easiest And Visually Best Way To Present And Analyze Appropriate Google Analytics Data Or Other Marketing-Related Data?

Similar to many agencies, our firm has started investigating and testing Google Looker Studio as a means to both visually present and analyze results since there are capabilities within the Studio to pull in data from a variety of sources — think Google Ads, Google Search Console, Google Analytics, CallRail, SEMRush and more — and automatically have the tool calculate changes in data from a previous time period.

We are still learning the ins and outs of Google Looker Studio but are very optimistic about how we can use it to tell a story with our clients’ data.

Want To Learn More About What Google Analytics Data You Should Be Analyzing With The Event Of AI? Wondering If Your Team Should Be Using Google Looker Studio to Present Results?

Schedule a complimentary time to meet with our digital marketing team to learn how we can help related to digital analytics and marketing analytics in the age of AI.

advertising agency, digital marketing agency, Google Ads, online advertising, paid search, pull marketing, push marketing, Results Analysis, sales, Search Engine Optimization, SEM, SEO, Strong Ad Creative, traditional marketing

The Challenges Of Display Advertising, A Form Of Push Marketing

While our firm has developed a specialty in, and has gotten well known locally for search engine optimization (SEO), i.e., both paid and organic tactics that drive individuals who are actively searching to identify someone who offers the products, services, and solutions to products you do to your website, we also have a lot of experience with “push marketing.” Unlike SEO-related marketing and tactics (pull marketing), push marketing is all about putting the idea about your organization’s products, services, and solutions into the heads of individuals who aren’t actively searching to identify someone like you, but who still might be a great fit for your product, service or solution, based on various demographics and behaviors. And, our blog post is focused on one form of push marketing — display advertising.

Who Does Display Advertising Target?

Like all forms of push marketing (think print, e-mail, and radio marketing), display advertising (advertising that includes an image vs. just text) allows you to target individuals and/or businesses based on one or more of these criteria about the individual or business:

  • the geography in which they live or are located
  • their age, gender, and household income, if an individual
  • key life events, such as graduating from college, having a baby or retiring, if an individual
  • their hobbies or interests
  • their role at a company
  • their recent purchase, or research conducted related to a potential purchase
  • the size or nature, if a company

So, What Is The Biggest Challenge Of Display Targeting?

Over the years, in both corporate marketing and consulting/agency roles, we’ve run a decent number of Google Ads, Facebook/Instagram, Reddit, Nextdoor.com and other “display campaigns” that have employed the targeting detailed above. But, with recent campaigns, it’s really struck us what one of the biggest challenges is related to running such campaigns to pursue individuals who aren’t necessarily looking to buy your products, services or solutions, but who might be a good fit for them.

And, that display advertising challenge is this. Many consumers and/or individuals associated with a business often click on ads, not because they have an immediate need for the product, service, or solution advertised nor will they ever have such a need. But rather, they click on ads out of what we call “the curiosity factor.” Something about the language and/or image in the ad — known as the “ad creative” sounds interesting or intriguing to them and they click on the ad to learn more just because they are curious.

This image shows part of the face and only one eye of a boy with dark hair and dark eyes peeling back brightly colored blue, gold, and purple curtains to look out the window.

How Does The Curiosity Factor Impact Display Advertising Results?

Here’s how individuals clicking on display ads simply out of curiosity impacts display advertising results:

  • Since for display ads, you often pay for ad “click,” you often pay for clicks that will never become a lead or sale.
  • The conversion rate for your ads is far lower than what you see with “paid search” campaigns (where ad clickers are in active search mode to identify someone like you) and your cost-per-conversion may end up being far higher than what you see with push marketing. The last statement depends on how much your cost-per-click is for your display campaign since often the cost-per-click is far lower than for a paid search campaign.
  • Ultimately your campaign ROI or ROAS (return on ad spend) ends up being quite low and doesn’t warrant continuing to spend on the campaign even though you’ve generated a lot of awareness of your products, services, and solutions thru your display ad spend.

Need Help Determining Whether Or Not It Makes Sense To Run A Display Advertising Campaign?

Our team is glad to chat with you on a complimentary basis about whether or not piloting a display campaign would make sense for your organization. Schedule a complimentary display advertising discussion today!

Acceptance of Circumstances, accountability, collaboration, partnerships, relationship building

Partnerships That Work: How Small Businesses Can Build Together Without Breaking Apart

Guest Blog Post by Charlie Michaels, Entrepreneurworld.net

Call it a partnership. Call it a handshake deal with paperwork behind it. Either way, most small business collaborations fail not from bad intent, but from slow, quiet unraveling. Communication thins. Assumptions spread. Someone thought they’d be handling inventory. Someone else thought they were only handling design. Then it turns out nobody handled billing. And it’s not just about misfires—sometimes, the core agreement was never clear to begin with. That’s what this is about. Not how to partner, but how to avoid having to un-partner later.

Most people think collaboration means “work together.” It doesn’t.

In decision-making research, there’s this concept called the prisoner’s dilemma. Two people, same goal, no trust. If both stay silent, both walk free. If one talks, the other suffers. If both talk, both get burned. What usually happens? They both talk. Not because they want to lose—because they don’t trust the other to stay quiet. That’s how most small business collaborations look when they’re rushed. Everyone’s hedging. No one’s quite sure what the other will do when things get hard. Partnerships only work when people are willing to lose a little power upfront, in service of something bigger.

This image shows three individuals, two young white men and one black woman dressed professionally, who are sitting around a conference room or office table discussing something.

Systems beat chemistry. Every time.

If a collaboration can’t survive a bad week, it wasn’t a collaboration. It was a fantasy. You need structure—deadlines, scopes, fallback plans. And not just in writing. Partners need to know how the whole thing fits together, especially when they’re not the one driving. The mental models that make collaboration effective aren’t about being nice. They’re about being predictable in the right ways, and adaptable in the right moments. Without that, people guess. And people are bad guessers under pressure.

If your foundation is wobbly, the partnership won’t fix it.

Before any deal, ask: is the business itself ready to collaborate? Or are you just looking for a lifeline? When ownership is unclear and obligations are fuzzy, partnerships just add complexity. Sometimes the best first move is to formalize your structure. When you start an LLC with ZenBusiness, you’re giving the collaboration something to stand on. Not just for liability. But for clarity. It’s a way of saying, “we’re taking this seriously,” and giving your future partners a reason to take you seriously too.

Good collaborations don’t look like press releases. They look like check-ins.

Most successful partnerships feel low-drama from the outside. But inside? They’re messy, iterative, a little chaotic. That’s a good sign. Case in point: one community-academic partnership engagement insight showed that regular recalibration—not perfect planning—is what kept them moving. In small business terms, that’s your weekly sync. That’s “what’s not working, and how are we going to deal with it?” done 50 times a year. If you’re waiting until something breaks to talk about process, you’re already behind.

Most local collaborations die in the weeds.

It’s easy to say “let’s partner locally.” It’s harder to map who else needs to be looped in. Permit offices, shared suppliers, unspoken community hierarchies. This isn’t corporate. Local partnerships operate more like ecosystems. And when people forget that, their projects stall. One systems science framework for collaboration mapped this exact thing. The collaborations that worked didn’t just share values—they understood their own position inside something bigger. Small business owners who think in systems—not just projects—tend to last longer in the room.

You can’t fix chaos with software.

No tool will rescue you from misalignment. Not Slack. Not Notion. Not that overpriced CRM everyone’s been talking about. Tools work when the team behind them is already synced. Otherwise, they’re just louder ways to be confused. The psychological foundations of effective teamwork have almost nothing to do with tech. It’s about who notices what. Who speaks up when something’s off. Who repairs, even if they weren’t the one who broke it. You want your collaboration to work? Build rhythm. Then pick your tools.

Don’t talk about goals. Show each other what you’ll give.

Want to know what really holds a partnership together after the shine wears off? Reciprocity. Not just “you do X, I do Y.” Deeper than that. “I’ll do this now, even if it’s invisible, because I know you’re doing something I can’t see yet too.” That’s what small business owners need to build into the DNA of their partnerships. Otherwise? You’re tracking favors. You’re building resentment spreadsheets. Keep the exchange visible. That’s how you keep the trust renewable.

Innovation doesn’t happen in brainstorms. It happens in maps.

Here’s the mistake: people think creativity means coming up with ideas together in real time. It doesn’t. It means knowing who to go to for what—and not wasting time reinventing what already works. That’s what shared memory systems are. That’s how effective teams scale: not by sharing everything, but by remembering who holds what. When that’s in place, you get real velocity. Not alignment theater. Not “we’re on the same page” speeches. Just movement.

Remember, don’t overcomplicate it. Good partnerships are built, not found. And most of what they need—clarity, rhythm, reciprocity—is fixable if someone’s paying attention. So pay attention. That’s the work.

Unlock the full potential of your business with Results Communications and Research, your go-to partner for strategic SEO and digital marketing solutions that drive visibility and growth.

About Our Guest Blogger, Charlie Michaels

Charlie Michaels created EntrepreneurWorld.net to connect and guide entrepreneurs all over the world! He came up with the idea in the midst of the pandemic. Feeling isolated and anxious, he thought other entrepreneurs, near and far, might be feeling the same way. He wanted to create a central digital gathering space where entrepreneurs could come to get support and learn from one another. Entrepreneur World is in its early stages, but Michaels is working hard to grow it to meet his big vision.